|
3. Agricultural Land-Use
3.1 Introduction
The beginning of agriculture dates back to a period in human
history almost ten to twelve thousand years ago. At this time, humans in
several different regions of the world began domesticating
several wild species of plants and animals. Some of the first crops to be
domesticated were the ancestors of today's modern grains. By continuously
replanting only the largest and healthiest of these plants over the centuries,
these once wild plants were selectively adapted to local
growing conditions. As a result of this selective breeding, present day strains
of rice, wheat, and other grains are far more productive than their acient
relatives.
Table 3.1: Original source region for various
modern crops grown in abundance today.
| Source Region |
Crop Domesticated |
| Palestine, Syria |
Wheat and Barley |
| Middle East |
Barley, Rye, Oats, Flax, Alfalfa, Plum and
Carrot |
| Mediterranean Basin |
Pea, Lentil and Bean |
| Southwest Asia |
Millet, Soybean, Radish, Tea, Peach, Apricot,
Orange and Lemon |
| Central Asia |
Spinach, Onion, Garlic, Almond, Pear and Apple
|
| India and Southeast Asia |
Rice, Cotton, Sugar Cane and Banana |
| Mexico and Central America |
Corn, New World Cotton, Sisal and Peppers
|
| South America |
Tomato, Potato, Peanut and Pineapple |
The rise of agriculture also brought about cultural and societial
changes to the early human population. In hunter gatherer
societies nearly everyone was involved in the collection of food.
However, early agriculture required a smaller proportion of human society to
produce food for the rest, allowing the people not involved in farming to
pursue other cultural endeavors. Early agriculture also allowed once nomadic
people to established themselves in one location.
Early agriculture was primarily subsistence in
nature. Farmers generally only grew enough food to feed the themselves and
their extended families. The invention of the plow
approximately 7000 years ago changed this practice. With the development of the
plow, food supplies and human population sizes could increase by simply
cultivating more land. As a result of the greater food supplied and increased
population growth,human communities began organizing in villages, towns,
cities, and nation states. While the devlopment of the plow had a positive
influence on the development of humankind, its influence on nature and the
environment was generally negative. Massive land clearing, for the purpose of
growing more food, destroyed and degraded the habitats of many types of
wildlife.
In the 19th and 20th centuries, humankind realized that the
growing human population was running short of new sources of land for
cultivation. A new technology had to be developed to expand food resources
without requiring more land for cultivation. Since 1950, sharp increases in
agricultural productivity have come from what is commonly called the
green revolution. The green revolution increased yields by
planting monocultures of hybrid crop varieties and by the application of large
amounts of inorganic fertilizer, irrigation water, and pesticides. Between
1950-1970, this approach resulted in dramatic increases in crop yields mainly
in more developed countries(MDCs ). After
1967, a variant of this 1st green revolution was transmitted
to many less developed countries(LDCs)
through MDC sponsored development projects. This 2nd
green revolution involved the cultivation of new high yield,
fast-growing dwarf varieties of rice and wheat, specially bred for tropical and
subtropical climates. However, achieving high yields with these new crops still
required large inputs of fertilizers, water and pesticides. For many
LDCs, these inputs are impractical because of their high cost.
Increasing agricultural productivity through green revolution
technologies relies heavily on the use of fossil fuels for running machinery
and producing fertilizers. Today, it now takes about 1.2 barrels of oil to
produce a single ton of grain in more developed countries. This is some seven
times greater than from 1950. Thus, industrial agriculture has become addicted
to oil, using about 8 % of world oil output. Many LDCs do not
have the finances to buy the oil needed to run an industrialized agricultural
system.
Future increases in production are predicted to come from genetic
engineering and other forms of biotechnology. In the next 20 to 40 years,
scientists hope to breed high yield plant strains that have greater resistance
to insects and disease, thrive on less fertilizer, make their own nitrogen
fertilizer like legumes, do well in slightly salty soils, and make more
efficient use of solar energy during photosynthesis. A good example of the
products that can be created from this type of research is
triticale. Triticale is a new cereal grain produced by cross
breeding wheat and rye. Triticale can flourish under a variety of conditions
including poor soils, and cold and hot climates.
Some analysts, however, point to several factors will limited the
spread and long-term success of the green revolutions. Thus, future increases
in agricultural productivity may be limited by:
- The availability of fertilzers and water. New crops required
huge amounts of fertilizers and water.
- Biological limitations. Plants have been far less responsive to
genetic engineering than animals.
- Climate and soil limitations. Areas without enough rainfall or
irrigation water or with poor soils cannot benefit from new varieties.
- Environmental degradation. Without careful land use and
environmental controls, degradation of water and soil can limit the long-term
ecological and economic sustainability of the green revolutions.
In the last few decades, many nations have also turned to the
oceans to supply some of their food resources. Using various harvesting
techniques, about 40 different species of marine organisms are caught for human
and livestock consumption. Of these forty species, Cod, Herring, Jack,
Mackerel, and Tuna account for over 60 % of the commercial fish harvested. From
1950 to 1990, the world catch of fish has increased by about 400 %. Because of
this drastic increase, the numbers of some species of fish have declined
substantially due to overfishing. In Canada, overfishing of North
Atlantic Cod has caused the government to take extreme actions to stop
the destruction of this fishery.
Another technique humans use to supplement their food resource
from the sea, is fish farming or aquaculture
. Fish farming involves cultivating aquatic species in a controlled
environment. Usually the controlled environment is a floating cage, a pond or
lake, or a fenced-in area of lake or ocean. In 1990, aquaculture supplied the
world with 15 % of its seafood. Of this 15 %, three-fourths of it comes from
LDCs.
Fish farming does create some ecological problems. For example,
the development of shrimp farming in Southeast Asia is responsible for the
clearing of millions of hectares of mangrove swamps. Mangrove swamps are the
home to several thousand different species of plants, birds, reptiles,
amphibians, fish, insects, and mammals.
3.2 Global Food
Resources
Of the 350,000 species of plants cataloged by science only about
one hundred crops are primarily used to feed the citizens of the world. About
15 plants and 8 animal species supply 90 % of our food. Wheat, rice, corn and
potato are the primary crops that provide us with the bulk of the starch we
consume. Other important crops, in order of production, include: barley, sweet
potato, cassava, grape, soybean, oats, sorghum, sugarcane, millet, banana,
tomato, sugar beet, rye, orange, coconut, cottonseed, apple, yam, peanut,
watermelon, cabbage, onion, bean, pea, sunflower seed, and mango. Fruits and
vegetables are valuable components of a healthy diet because they provide high
levels of vitamins, oils, minerals, proteins and fiber.
Other foods consumed include fish, meat and animal products such
as milk, eggs, and cheese. For most of the people on this planet meat and
animal products, like milk, are too expensive to consume. As a result, 80 % of
the meat and milk produced is consumed by only 20 % of the world's population.
The raising of livestock on the Earth's land surface is creating some important
environmental problems. Pasture and open
range now occupies 24 % of the Earth's terrestrial surface and
supports more than 3 billion domestic grazing animals. Over grazing by these
animals is causing desertification, chemical and physical soil degradation,
accelerated erosion, and plant biodiversity reductions.
Table 3.2 describes the countries with the
largest areas in production of crops. The table also supplies information on
amount of cropland per capita (1991), average percentage of land being
irrigated (1989-91), average amount of fertilizer applied in kilograms per
hectare (1989-91), average production of cereals (1990-92), and average cereal
yield in kilograms per hectare (1990-92). The total amount of arable land
worldwide is about 1,441 million hectares. The Russian Federation, which
contains about 2.7 % of the Earth's inhabitants, currently cultivates about 213
million hectares or about 15 % of the world's cropland. Most of this production
is sold to other countries or is used to feed livestock. The most efficient
farmers are found in China. With 22 % of the world's population, the Chinese
have to make do with only 6.7 % of the Earth's arable cropland. Yet, their
population is well fed because intensive subsistence farming techniques produce
yields equivalent to those produced in countries practicing industrialized
farming. However, intensive subsistence agriculture requires large inputs of
human labor, irrigation and fertilization in order to achieve these yields.
Most of the cereal production in the United States, Canada,
Russian Federation and Australia is not used to feed humans directly. Most of
this food is used to feed livestock which are used for dairy products, eggs or
slaughtered for meat. This process of creating food is highly inefficient. As
discussed earlier in this course, the efficiency of animals to assimilate food
energy is less than 10 %. In fact, it takes about 16 kilograms of grain and
soybeans to produce 1 kilogram of edible beef.
| Table 3.2 : Top Fifteen Countries in Terms
of Land Under Crop Cultivation. Statistics Also Describing: Cropland Per Capita
in Hectares (1991); Average Percent Land Irrigated (1989-91); Average Annual
Fertilizer Used in Kg Per Hectare (1989-91); Average Cereal Production in 1000s
of Metric Tons (1990-1992); and Cereal Yield Per Hectare in Kilograms
(1990-92). ( Source : Food and Agriculture Organization of the
United Nations and the United Nations Population Division.) |
|
Country |
Cropland 000s of Hectares
(1991) |
Cropland Per Capita in
Hectares (1991) |
Average Percent Land Irrigated
(1989-91) |
Average Annual Fertilizer Used
in Kg Per Hectare (1989-91) |
Average Cereal Production in 1000s
of Metric Tons (1990-1992) |
Cereal Yield Per Hectare in
Kilograms (1990-92) |
| Russian Federation |
212,800 |
1.44 |
3 % |
52 |
100,220 |
1,701 |
| Kazakhstan |
197,300 |
11.79 |
1 % |
3 |
23,218 |
1,013 |
| United States |
187,776 |
0.74 |
10 % |
99 |
315,486 |
4,881 |
| India |
169,700 |
0.20 |
27 % |
73 |
196,173 |
1,935 |
| China |
96,554 |
0.08 |
49 % |
284 |
399,927 |
4,329 |
| Brazil |
61,350 |
0.40 |
4 % |
54 |
37,816 |
1,924 |
| Australia |
46,877 |
2.70 |
4 % |
26 |
22,214 |
1,691 |
| Canada |
45,930 |
1.70 |
2 % |
46 |
52,855 |
2,531 |
| Turkmenistan |
35,610 |
9.71 |
3 % |
7 |
571 |
2,398 |
| Ukraine |
34,629 |
0.67 |
8 % |
126 |
39,994 |
3,094 |
| Nigeria |
32,335 |
0.29 |
3 % |
12 |
13,111 |
1,205 |
| Turkey |
27,689 |
0.48 |
9 % |
65 |
30,129 |
2,202 |
| Argentina |
27,200 |
0.83 |
6 % |
6 |
21,974 |
2,610 |
| Uzbekistan |
26,100 |
1.27 |
16 % |
41 |
1,985 |
1,840 |
| Mexico |
24,720 |
0.29 |
21 % |
69 |
24,662 |
2,430 |
3.3 Industrial
Agriculture and the Environment
As previously mentioned, modern day agriculture has been
responsible for dramatically increasing the food supply. However, many of the
practices used by industrial farmers can cause damage to nature or can be
extremely limited by normal variablity in the environment.
3.3.1 Erosion and
Soil Degradation
Recent increases in the human population have placed a great
strain on the world's soil systems. More that 5.5 billion people are now using
about 10 % of the land area of the Earth to raise crops and livestock. When
used for such purposes, soils can suffer various types of degradation that can
ultimately reduce their ability to produce food resources.
Erosion
is the number one factor degrading soils globally. Erosion is a process where
wind and water facilitate the movement of top
soil from one place to another. Water erosion is more detrimental to soils
globally both by the volume of soil removed and area of land influenced. Soils
are normally protected from erosion by the above- and below-ground parts of
plants. Above-ground parts of plants, like stems and leaves, reduce the
potential of wind and water to erode soils by acting as barriers to these
mediums. Plants can also reduce erosion by binding and anchoring soil particles
to roots.
Agriculture increases the risk of erosion through its
disturbance of vegetation by way of land-use conversion, tilling or
overgrazing. Many farmers prepare land by tilling or ploughing their fields to
produce a smooth planting surface devoid or vegetation. This process, however,
creates a soil surface that is very vulnerable to erosion. In Canada and the
United States, some farmers have been using a technique known as
conservation tillage or zero tillage to
reduce the erosion problem. This technique uses special machinery and
herbicides to plant crops with minimal disturbance to the soil surface.
The following agricultural practices lead to accelerated soil
erosion:
- Overgrazing of animals (where more animals are raised than
the forage can sustain). Trampling and eating diminishes the number of species
grown in a particular forage area, and without adequate vegetative cover the
land becomes more susceptible to both wind and rain erosion. Further when
animals are grazed in riparian areas (areas next to streams) , the trampling
near the stream banks causes erosion and stream sedimentation.
- Planting of a monoculture. This practice can lead to erosion
for several reasons. First, a monoculture is harvested all at one time, which
leaves the entire field bare and the natural rainfall is not retained by the
soil and flows rapidly over the surface rather than into the ground. Secondly,
if a disease or pests invade the area, the entire crop is usually wiped out and
again leaving the bare soil susceptible to the elements.
- Row cropping. This agricultural practice is common with
monocultures but can also be found in polycultures. This technique exposes the
soil between each row of crops which is then vulnerable to erosion.
- Tilling or plowing. This is one of the oldest agricultural
practices, it involves mixing up the nutrients within the soil, loosening the
soil particles, incorporating oxygen and getting rid of weeds, however, it also
increases the likelihood of erosion because it disturbs the natural surface and
protective vegetation.
- Crop removal. The continuous removal of crops does not only
increase the soil susceptibility to erosion due to exposure but it also
increases it because the organic matter in the soil is depleted. Organic matter
has the ability to absorb a lot of rainwater and without it, erosion is
increased because water doesn't soak into the soil.
- Development of new land. This is a problem particularly in
the least developed countries. Rising populations are forcing people onto
marginal lands to grow crops. Hillsides are not developed properly, and are
very vulnerable to erosion when water passes over them.
Many of these practices have resulted in degraded land across
the globe. Slight degradation refers to land where yield potential has been
reduced by 10 %, 10-50 % yield potential reduction is referred to as moderate
degradation and severely degraded is land that has lost more than 50 % of its
potential yield.
Problems of soil ersion can be stopped, and certain techniques
can lead to soil enhancement and rebuilding. The techniques commonly used are:
1. Plowing style. The way in
which a field is plowed can have a substantial effect on the amount of erosion
that occurs. The following techniques are commonly used to reduce ersions:
a) Contour farming. This method involves
tilling the field at right angles to the slope of the land. The ridges that are
created act like a dam to hold the water while it soaks into the soil rather
than running down the slope taking the soil with it. Contour farming has the
ability to reduce erosion by up to 50%.
b) Terracing. This is another way of preparing
the fields for planting and is usually used on much steeper slopes, by leveling
off areas on the slope to prevent the flow of water down it. There are
disadvantages to terracing however, in that the terraces themselves can be
easily eroded and they generally require a lot of maintenance and repair.
2. Timing. The time which a field is tilled can
have a major effect on the amount of erosion that takes place during the year.
If a field is plowed in the fall, erosion can take place all winter long,
however if ground cover remains until spring, there isn't as much time for the
erosion to take place.
3. No-till Cultivation. Specialized machinery
is available that can loosen the soil, plant seeds and take care of weed
control all at once with minimum disturbance to the soil. Since all of these
aspects are taken care of at one time there is less time for erosion to occur.
There is a trade off though, weed and insect populations can increase which
compete or destroy crops because they are not continuously being removed.
4. Farming Method. There are several ways in
which a field can be cultivated in order to avoid erosion:
a) Strip Farming. This involves planting crops
in widely spaced rows but filling in the spaces with another crop to ensure
complete ground cover. The ground is completely covered so it retards water
flow so that it soaks into the soil consequently reducing erosion problems.
b) Polyvarietal cultivation (where the soil is
planted with several varieties of the same crop). As harvest times vary for the
different varieties of the crop, results in protection from erosion because the
entire field is not exposed all at once.
c) Trees act to protect against the mechanical
damage and drying effects of the wind.
5. Adding Organic Matter. The addition of
organic matter to the soil is important and can be achieved by plowing in crop
residues or an entire crop grown specifically to be plowed into the ground
(green manure). Microbes in the soil decompose the organic matter and produce
polysaccharides which are sticky and act to glue soil particles together and
help it to resist erosion.
Even though there are many, simple, methods for reducing erosion
many farmers choose not to use them because short-term costs of implementing
these practices outweigh the short-term benefits. For example, it is more
expensive in terms of time and machinery required for a farmer to plant several
crops on the same piece of land than it is to plant one single crop variety.
3.3.2 Fertilizer
Use and Abuse
All plants require a certain quantity of nutrients to support
growth.
Macronutrients
are nutrients which a plant requires in large quantities (such as carbon,
oxygen, nitrogen and phosphorus).
Micronutrients
are also essential for plant growth but are required in much smaller doses,
nutrients include iron, copper, manganese and zinc. Some of the macro and
micronutrients are readily available from the environment such as carbon,
hydrogen and oxygen. Others, such as nitrogen, have to be converted into a
usable form for plants. Even though the atmosphere is approximately 78 %
nitrogen, none of this can be used by plants directly, instead it has to be
converted to such products as nitrate by the bacteria that live on roots and in
the soils. The replacement of nutrients to the soil is very important because
once a crop is harv ested the nutrients that it used for growth are permanently
lost from the soil. If the same crop is grown repeatedly on the same field (as
is done in conventional agriculture) many of the micronutrients are depleted
such as boron, zinc and manganese. Other macronutrients, such as nitrogen, are
often in short supply because they cannot be retained by the soil. Nitrogen, is
one nutrient that plants require in large quantities as it is a major
constituent of proteins and nucleic acids, however as mentioned earlier is
often available in short supply.
Inorganic fertilizers were developed to increase plant yields by
supplying plants with the necessary nutrients that are in short supply to
stimulate growth. Inorganic fertilizers are commonly composed of nitrogen,
phosphorus and potassium. Ammonia is not the sole form of nitrogen in
fertilizers. Nitrogen can also be in the form of urea or ammonium nitrate,
however ammonia must be synthesized first because it is used to prepare these
other nitrogen forms.
Generally inorganic fertilizers have the benefits that they
produce high yields, are easy to apply and are relatively inexpensive. The
price, however, can vary because the production of fertilizer relies so heavily
on oil and consequently its price in the world market. It is believed that
approximately 25% of the worlds crops today are directly attributable to the
use of inorganic fertilizers and due to this success, the demand for
fertilizers has been doubling every 10 years.
Although inorganic fertilizer is responsible for dramatically
increasing yields there are several drawbacks to its continued use:
Energy Requirements. The amount of energy to
produce the nitrogen portion of the fertilizers is massive, taking almost
18,000 kilocalories of energy per one kilogram of nitrogen, using up a lot of
the world's oil reserves. Phosphate and potassium also require energy for
extraction but not nearly the extravagant amounts required for nitrogen
production (3,000 and 2,300 kilocalories per kilogram respectively). There is
concern, however, if projected increases in fertilizer use become reality it is
believed that the potassium reserves will only last 107 years and the phosphate
deposits only 88 years.
Organic Matter Decline. A big problem with
inorganic fertilizers is that they do not replace the organic matter in the
soil that is lost when a plant is harvested. Organic matter is very important
in the soil for a number of reasons. It modifies the soil structure by
preventing compacting and maintains pore spaces for water and air movement to
the roots. It's decomposition product, humus, lowers the soil pH releasing
nutrients that are available in the soil for plant uptake. Organic matter is
also an important energy source for bacteria which are vital in the carbon and
nitrogen cycles.
Greenhouse Effect. Research has demonstrated
that fertilized fields emit 2 to 10 times as much nitrous oxide as unfertilized
soils and pastures. Emission rates are increased in temperate climates. In
addition, the use of fossil fuels for the production of ammonia emit carbon
dioxide into the atmosphere a very important greenhouse gas.
Leaching. Many farmers apply more fertilizer to
the crops than can be taken up by the plants. Nitrogen is the most susceptible
to leaching because it cannot be retained by the soil. Phosphates can react
with other minerals in the soil forming insoluble compounds and the amount of
potassium leached is influenced by the cation exchange capacity of the soil.
These excess nutrients can contaminate ground water and surface water. Nitrates
in the drinking water can be harmful and are thought to be carcinogenic. In
surface waters, fertilizers can stimulate growth of algae and other aquatic
plants, when these plants die they consume oxygen ultimately leading to
eutrophic waters.
Health Hazards. Some nitrogen containing
fertilizers are hazardous to human health. Ammonia, for instance is toxic and
can be very reactive with some substances. Ammonium nitrate, another common
fertilizer is explosive so extreme care must be taken during manufacturing and
storage.
Total dependency on chemical fertilizer not only changes the
chemical, physical and biotic properties of the soil, but is endangering other
environmental aspects. There are several ways to reduce the damage being caused
by inorganic fertilizers:
Reduce Leaching. One method to reduce leaching
losses of fertilizers (and subsequently protect water resources) is to apply
inorganic fertilizers at a rate which is equal to plant uptake. This involves
applying small quantities of fertilizers several times over the growing season
to allow the plants to use them rather than apply them all at once at the
beginning.
Green Manure. The concept of green manure is
growing some sort of vegetation on the field for the sole purpose of plowing it
into the ground. This not only increases the amount of organic matter in the
soil which has numerous benefits but it also increases nutrient availability to
the next crop that is grown there.
Use Animal Fertilizers. Animal manure is a
cheap fertilizer source especially if the animals are already on the farm. The
nutrients are released slowly into the soil for plant uptake and it also
increases the organic matter in the soil. Animal fertilizers have the
disadvantage that they generally don't contain a lot of nitrogen and sometimes
release of other nutrients is too slow.
New Crop Biotechnology. Scientists are trying
to develop new strains of crops to fix their own nitrogen (a trait of legumes).
If researchers are successful then the demand for nitrogen fertilizers would be
greatly reduced as they would no longer be required.
Crop Rotation. By rotating the field with
different crops reduces the amount of nutrients depleted because different
plants require varying amounts of nutrients. Fields that are planted with corn
or cotton (crops that remove a lot of nutrients, especially nitrogen) one year
should be replaced by legumes or some other crops which have the ability to
replace nutrients.
Intercropping. Intercropping involves growing
two or more different crops on the same piece of land. Crops such as corn which
depletes soil nitrogen can be planted right along side legumes which replenish
it, again reducing the need for any chemical fertilizer inputs.
3.3.3 Pesticide Use
and Abuse
3.3.3.1 Introduction
A pesticide is a substance, or mixture of
substances, that is used in the control of pests. Pesticides include all
materials that are used to prevent, destroy, repel, attract, or reduce pest
organisms. A pest is any living organism which has the ability
to harm people or damage property. Therefore, pesticides are used in many
different applications such as forestry, landscaping, agriculture, and domestic
use. Examples of pests include plant parasitic viruses, bacteria, nematodes,
fungi, insects, weeds, rodents, and birds. Many of these pests cause extreme
damage to various agricultural products resulting in various economic losses.
Pesticide use has been prevalent for thousands of years.
Ancient Romans demonstrated the use of pesticides by burning sulphur in an
attempt to control insects. The early Chinese civilization controlled the pests
of crops by using arsenic and pyrethrum. They also used ground tobacco to
control the aphid population. During the 19th century in France, a copper-lime
mixture was used to control mildew on crops. Pesticides first became widely
used in the beginning of the 20th century with the development of intensive
agriculture. By the early 20th century, two classes of pesticides were
primarily used. These included botanicals, natural chemicals derived from plant
material, and inorganic salts which were widely used as fungicides, herbicides
and insecticides.
Before World War II, only a few synthetically produced
pesticides were used including DDT, dinitrophenols, hydrogen
cyanide, naphthalene and methyl bromide. Since World War II, a large number of
synthetic organic pesticides have been developed, and now over 600 basic
pesticides and chemicals have been incorporated into over 5000 brand name
products which have been registered for use in Canada. The discovery of
DDT in 1934 (dichloro-diphenyl-trichloroethane) was a major
advance in chemicals which possessed insecticidal properties. This chemical was
highly toxic to insects, relatively non-toxic to mamals, inexpensive, stable,
soluable in water, and easily sprayed of infested areas. Its early use was
especially beneficial in World War II in tropical areas where disease and
parasites took their toll on soldiers. Okanagan fruit growers used the
pesticide DDT in the early 1940s to fight infestations of codling moths.
However, by the 1960s the codling moth began to show r esistance to DDT and
other methods of control had to be implemented. The use of DDT in Canada and
the United States was eventually banned because of its persistence in the food
chains of lower animals and its damage to bird life.
Globally, about 2.5 million tons of pesticides are applied
annually to control pest organisms. Most of this application is targeted on
agricultural crops. Pesticides make a significant contribution to increasing
agricultural production. Pimentel et al. (BioScience 42(10):
750-760) estimate that for each dollar invested in pesticide control about four
dollars of crops is saved. Pesticides also have many risks associated with
their use. These risks include human health effects, livestock animal
poisoning, beneficial insect losses, water contamination, wildlife losses, and
the genetic evolution of pesticide resistance.
3.3.3.2 Types
of Pesticides
Pesticides can be classified according to their chemical
structure:
Inorganic pesticides are broad-based poisons
made from common natural chemicals like arsenic, copper, lead and mercury.
These chemicals are generally highly toxic and indestructible. Because of these
two features, these chemicals can accumulate in the environment.
Natural or organic
pesticides are generally compounds extracted from plants. Many plants, like
tobacco, chrysanthemum, and conifers, have evolved the ability to produce
secondary substances that are used to deter herbivore
consumption.
Fumigants are specific compounds in gaseous
form that are used to sterilize soil and prevent pest infestation of stored
grain. The use of these chemicals has been banned or reduced in many parts of
the world because of the extreme danger associated to workers with their
application.
Chlorinated hydrocarbons are synthetic
organic compounds that effect the nervous system of the pest. They include such
chemicals as DDT, chlordane, alrin, dieldrin, toxaphene, paradichlorobenzene,
and lindane. These chemicals are highly resistant to decomposition and can
remain in ecosystems up to 15 years.
Organophosphates are synthetic chemicals that
have been developed as a by-product of human nerve gas research during World
War II. These chemicals are 10 to 100 times more toxic than chlorinated
hydrocarbons to animals larger than insects. However, their persistence in the
environment is quite short, usually in the order of hours to days. Some
examples of organophosphates include parathion, malthion, dichlorvos,
dimethyldichlorovinylphosphate (DDVP), and tetraethylpyrophosphate (TEPP).
Carbamates are urethanes that effect the
nervous system of pests. They are very similar to organophosphates, and include
such chemicals as carbaryl (Sevin), aldicarb (Temik), aminocarb (Zineb),
carbofuran (Baygon), and Mirex.
Microbial agents are living organisms that
are used to control pests. Some examples of microbial agents include lady bugs,
parasitic wasps, virus, and specific forms of bacteria.
3.3.3.3
Pesticides and the Environment
Up to 90 % of the pesticides applied never reach the intended
targets. As a result, many other organisms sharing the same environment as the
pests are accidentally poisoned. Human pesticide poisonings are clearly the
most ontroversial. In 1989, the World Health Organization and United Nations
Environmental Program released the publication ' Public Health Impact
of Pesticides Used in Agriculture' which reported that there are about
1 million human pesticide poisonings and 20,000 deaths each year. Many other
types of non-pest organisms are also adversely effected by pesticide
application. During the 1950s and 1960s several species of birds, including
osprey, cormorant, brown pelican, bald eagle, prairie falcon, sparrow hawk, and
peregrine falcon, were severely effected the pesticide DDT. Scientists
discovered that a chemical derived from the DDT weakened the egg shells of
these birds, reducing their ability to reproduce. In the US, estimates suggest
that 20 % of honeybee colonies are eradicated by pesticide application.
3.3.3.4
Pesticide Contamination: Water Resources
Contamination of groundwater and surface water by pesticides
is a very common problem. Some of the important factors that influence the
degree of contamination include:
- Permeability of the soil between the surface and
groundwater table which affects the movement of water and pesticides toward the
ground water.
- Physical properties of the soil may impede or influence the
movement of pesticide contaminated water to groundwater
- depth of groundwater from the surface.
- Slope of the ground surface which controls the direction of
runoff movement, shorter steeper slopes increase the likeliness of
contamination.
- Distance of the pesticide application area to surface
water.
Pesticides can reach water resulting from direct treatment
used to control pests, or indirectly. Pesticides can contaminate aquatic
systems by fallout from aerial sprays, soil erosion, or through the disposal of
pesticide containers or effluent from pesticide factories. Those pesticides
which are soluble in water may be carried by nearby waters by surface runoff.
0.5 to 15 % of a pesticide treatment can be carried into an aquatic system due
to runoff from agricultural land. Waters are also contaminated through
pesticide drift during application, and atmospheric fallout on rain and dust.
Once the pesticide reaches the water system, its distribution
and fate will depend on its persistence and solubility Most pesticides that
persist in a water system usually become adsorbed (bound to the soil particle)
onto floating particles and settle out as sediment. Some pesticides may remain
here for a number of years and may re-enter the water due to the disturbance of
sediment. Generally, the more persistent a pesticide is, the greater the effect
it will have on the aquatic ecosystem. Also, the more soluble a pesticide is ,
the greater its potential is for aquatic system and groundwater contamination.
The persistence of a pesticide in water depends on the nature of the water it
is in. Factors affecting the persistence of a pesticide in a water system
include water composition, pH, temperature, aquatic life present and amount of
suspended organic and inorganic material.
The results of pesticide contamination of water systems, both
surface and groundwater are the organisms living in and using the water are
affected such as humans, domestic animals, fish, birds, plants and wildlife.
Many modern pesticides are particularly toxic to water-dwelling insects,
plankton, crustaceans and fish.
Agriculture Canada has reported that soil in the Okanagan area
is generally low in organic matter. This increases degradation time, and
decreases the degree to which the pesticide decays before it is transported
from the soil layer to parts of the hydrologic cycle. The net result of this
process is generally higher contamination levels in groundwater and surface
water in lakes and rivers.
3.3.3.5
Pesticide Contamination: The Atmosphere
There are many ways in which pesticides reach the atmosphere.
These include: spray drift during application; volatilisation during
application; volatilisation from treated surfaces; escape from pesticide
manufacturing and formulating plants. The amount of drift is a function of
atmospheric conditions, application equipment, the pesticide being applied, and
the height of release of the pesticide. Volatilisation of secondary deposition
can also occur where the water droplets or dust particles which have returned
to the Earth are subject to evaporation once again. Although pesticides can
volatilize into the atmosphere from water surfaces, volatilization generally
occurs soon after application.
Many studies have demonstrated that pesticides are in the
atmosphere are present as either particulate matter or in the vapour phase. The
inhalation of these pesticides can be toxic for many organisms.
The ultimate fate of pesticide residues in the air is poorly
understood, but evidence suggests that these residues are globally transported
over long distances, carried into the upper atmosphere, or fall back to the
Earth in precipitation. Some pesticide residues may also be broken down by
light in the upper atmosphere.
3.3.3.6
Pesticide Contamination: The Biosphere
Over the last few decades, the variety and amounts of
pesticides have greatly increased, resulting in some beneficial effects on the
agricultural industry. However, there have been many reported cases of wildlife
kills due to improper pesticide use. There is concern of the effects of
pesticides on wildlife due to direct effects as well as long term exposure to
low levels of pesticides. This exposure may cause death or result in sublethal
effects. Sublethal effects do not cause mortality, but reduce the population
through sterilization effects or weakening of the organism resulting in its
inability to escape from prey. Pesticides may also alter the physical habitat
of many organisms or damage food sources. Once one species in an ecosystem is
altered by pesticides, many other species will also be affected due to the high
level of interactions within the ecosystem.
Pesticides are often concentrated within food chains as these
chemicals are passed from one organism to another as the result of consumption.
Because of this process, pesticides tend to accumulated in large organisms that
do a lot of consuming. Birds appear to be the major targets of pesticide
pollution in almost every type of ecosystem. The types of birds that are
particularly affected are those at the top of the
grazing
food chain. This includes birds of prey like eagles, hawks, and owls.
Plant, insect, and grain-feeding birds are also susceptible. It is very
difficult to protect birds from pesticide poisoning, especially when highly
toxic pesticides are used. Chlorinated hydrocarbons have been implicated in the
decline of several bird populations by interfering with their reproductive
process. This is caused by either delayed breeding or the discontinuance of
egg-laying. Eggs that are laid are thin and easily broken, leading to high
mortality rates.
There have been many adverse effects of pesticides on birds
that have been reported in the Thompson-Okanagan. Bird populations found living
in habitats in and adjacent to orchards have frequently been found exhibiting
the harmful effects of pesticides. When DDT was used, along with other
organochlorine pesticides, the breeding success of predator species, such as
osprey and peregrines decreased. More recently, a study was performed by the
Canadian Wildlife Service on pesticide residues in wild bird eggs. This study
was done on swallows and bluebirds in 1990, and quail and pheasants in 1991. It
showed that the levels of a breakdown product of DDT, called DDE, were 10 times
higher in the eggs of the birds from the Penticton-Naramata area than the
control area. Even though DDT has been banned for years, this pesticide and its
breakdown products still persist in the environment, and have not yet
disappeared.
Another type organism often poisoned by pesticides is fish.
Fish kills have resulted from agricultural contamination of waterways due to
atmospheric fallout, drainage, runoff erosion, and from the discharge of
industrial effluents containing pesticides into the waterways. Also, many of
the organisms on which fish feed are susceptible to pesticide poisoning, which
may affect the fish population.
When pesticides are applied broadly outdoors, there is a great
danger of poisoning honeybees, wild bees or other beneficial insects. This can
result from:
- The drift of pesticide sprays or dusts onto nearby crops or
weeds that are currently in bloom.
- Application of pesticides to crops during the blooming
season.
- Contamination of flowering cover crops and weeds during
orchard spraying.
- Contamination of water, pollen or nectar.
Large economic losses may result from weakened hives or
reduced honey production due to pesticides application. Also, some bees are
extremely important in the pollination of specific crops and wild plants, and
are therefore very beneficial
3.3.3.7
Pesticide Contamination: Humans
The environmental effects of pesticides on wildlife, soil and
water all strongly impact the quality of human life. Pesticide residues may
also cause contamination of drinking water and food. There have been many
reports of small pesticide residues in various foods. Over the last 50 years
many human illnesses and deaths have occurred as a result of pesticide
contamination, up to 20,000 deaths per year. These are mostly due to accidental
exposure of farm workers and sprayers to pesticides. Accidental exposure may
result from improper handling, or the use of insufficient protective clothing
when applying pesticides.
One potentially very harmful effect of pesticide use is the
ability of pesticides to interfere with the endocrine system (which produces
hormones) and the immune system of animals and humans. The concentration of
pesticides required to cause this type of damage can be very small, leading to
increasing concerns involving pesticide use.
Almost all pesticides can be fatal if present in large enough
quantities, but organophosphates are found to be the most harmful and toxic.
Small amounts of chlorinated hydrocarbons have been found to be present in the
body fat of humans. The main source of this is contaminated food. Long-term
effects of pesticide exposure can lead to cancer, mutations and congenital
defects.
3.3.3.8
Alternatives to Pesticides
There are many alternative methods to pesticide use which are
less damaging to the environment. Some of the more common methods include:
Mechanical/Physical Control - hand-picking,
screens or traps, electricity, light, heat, or cold storage.
Cultural Control - the manipulation of the
environment to produce conditions which are less favourable for pests.For
example, orchards can be cleaned of drying wood which is a breeding ground for
wood infesting beetles; soil tillage can be used to interfer with the life
cycles of insect pests. The rotation of crops can eliminate pest species which
survive year after year on the same crop.
Biological Control - involves the release or
enhancement of predators, parasites, or diseases to control or manage a
population of pest species.
Regulatory Control - this involves an attempt
to regulate commerce, farming, and other human activities that affect the
distribution and prevalence of destructive insect pests. This type of control
has the ability to slow down the movement of insect pests until research can
develop adequate control measures.
Integrated Pest Management (
IPM) - currently is the most common alternative to the use of
pesticides being used. IPM is an approach to crop protection which combines a
number of techniques in an organised fashion in an attempt to suppress pest
populations. This management is generally accepted as the most desirable and
effective approach to protection from insects, mites, disease, weeds, and other
pests. The aim of IPM is to prevent economic loss resulting
from pests as well as to avoid harm to people, non-target organisms (plants and
animals) and the environment. However, the object of IPM is not to control 100
% of the pests in an area.
IPM is needed due to the over-reliance on pesticides that has
developed since their rapid emergence. This over-reliance has lead to
contamination of the environment and the development of pesticide resistant
species.
The IPM method involves several steps which are listed below:
- Identification of the problem. The more information that is
known about the target pest organism, such as the biology of the organism, the
behaviour, enemies and life cycles, the more effective the treatment will be.
- Monitor the pest populations. This provides the information
needed to make decisions about the timing of treatments and the necessity of
them.
- Establish the injury level or the unacceptable level of
damage from a particular pest. This level is usually the economic injury level
when dealing with agricultural crops.
- Establish the action level. When the action level is
reached the particular treatment is applied to prevent the injury level from
being reached.
- Develop treatment plan. One treatment or a combination of
several treatments are co-ordinated into a program to control the pest
organism. This may include the combination of biological controls, cultural
controls, physical or mechanical controls, or use of a low level of chemical
controls.
- Evaluation of the pest management program. This is
necessary to determine the success or the IPM program, so improvements can be
made and the benefits can be determined.
Generally in IPM programs, pesticides are used only if their
application is absolutely required. If they are used, the pesticides are
usually of low toxicity and break down quickly in the environment. They are
also applied as efficiently as possible.
Various IPM programs are extensively used the tree fruit
production in the Thompson-Okanagan area. All of these programs differ in the
number and types of controls which have been integrated.
- Orchard mite control using IPM involves application of
dormant oil, regular assessment of pest and predatory mite numbers, only
necessary miticide application avoiding chemicals which are highly toxic to the
predators of the target mites.
- IPM of fruit tree and European leafroller involves
monitoring, application of a chemical and/or biological control treatment if
needed, and proper pruning for removal of eggs and for effective spray
penetration.
- The pear psylla IPM program involves the application of
dormant oil, preservation of natural enemies through reduced pesticide use or
the use of less toxic pesticides, and monitoring psylla and natural enemies to
assess the need and the timing of spray. Pear Psylla has been heavily damaging
Okanagan pear crops to the point that growers maintain it could cause the pear
industry to be wiped out unless these types of IPM programs are introduced.
Psylla causes fruit rusting leaf blackening and affects fruit size.
- Orchard floor vegetation should be monitored to minimize
rodent damage and nutrient and water competition to fruit trees. The orchard
floor vegetation may also provide a habitat which is suitable for the natural
enemies of potential fruit tree pests.
- IPM is also used for control of the codling moth in the
apple and pear orchards of the Thompson-Okanagan region.
IPM is becoming more and more accepted as both an
environmentally and an economically preferable approach to pest management. A
move is being made away from conventional pesticide use to a more environmental
friendly approach to pest management. British Columbia is one of the world
leaders in the development and application of IPM programs.
3.3.4 Irrigation
and Water Pollution
Irrigation in combination with inorganic fertilizers and
pesticides have resulted in dramatic increases in crop yields in the twentieth
century. The quantity of water that is being used for irrigation is threatening
the world's fresh water supply not to mention degrading soils. Data has shown
that between 1960 and 1980 the spread of irrigation was responsible for almost
60% of the massive increase in agricultural output in developing countries. In
addition other agricultural practices are having a huge impact on the aquatic
environment.
Water use. Many crops are being grown in
climates that could not otherwise support them largely due to the developments
in irrigation. Irrigation systems only average a 40% efficiency rate, with the
remaining of the applied water being lost to evaporation, runoff, infiltrating
below the root zone or seepage from unlined canals before it even is applied to
the fields. This low efficiency in combination with dramatic use has depleted
water supplies in many areas.
a) Ground water. Many farms that do not have streams or
rivers nearby rely on ground water for irrigation purposes. Numerous aquifers,
however, are in danger of drying up do to overuse by so many people. A good
example is the Ogalla aquifer in the Southern United States which has over
175,000 wells tapped into it, irrigating over 15 million acres of land is being
depleted at a much faster rate then its natural rate of recharge. Texas is
removing water from this aquifer at a rate 40 times higher than it can
naturally be replenished.
b) Surface water. For irrigation purposes, rivers and
streams are diverted from their natural courses. Lowering water levels in
rivers and streams can alter habitats so that aquatic life can no longer
survive there. A dramatic example water diversion is the Aral Sea in the Soviet
Union where diversion of water from rivers and streams running into it has
reduced the sea to one sixth its 1960 size and all native fish species have
disappeared.
Salinization. Farmers generally have a tendency to over
irrigate their crops to ensure that they are receiving enough moisture, this
practice, however, can increase salinity both in the soil and in water
supplies.
a) Soil salinity. When crops are over irrigated, the
surplus water evaporates and the salts that are dissolved in it are left behind
increasing the salinity of the soil. Increased soil salinity can cause a
decrease in plant productivity and interferes with water uptake by plants.
Fruit crops are the most sensitive to soil salinity followed by vegetables and
then field and forage crops. Generally the problem is inadequately solved by
flushing the root zone with excess water, which generally ends up contaminating
the ground water or irrigation canals. The water is then reapplied to crops
either on the same field or somewhere else downstream resulting in the same
problem over again.
b) Groundwater salinity. Irrigation does not only cause
increases in soil salinity, it can also increase salinity in ground water.
Water at the bottom of an aquifer rests against bedrock (which contains salt)
so it generally is more saline than water above it. As water is withdrawn from
the aquifer it approaches an area of increasing salinity, resulting in the
previously outlined problems.
Waterlogging. This results when soils are over irrigated.
Generally waterlogging occurs in areas that have clayey soils or an impermeable
layer of clay that lies beneath the surface, so water cannot move efficiently
through the soil and cannot adequately be drained. Eventually the soil root
zone becomes saturated with so much water that plant roots can no longer obtain
adequate amounts of oxygen for growth and the soils are no longer suitable for
cultivation.
Sediment. Sediment is the largest surface water pollutant
by volume and is the result of erosion. Intensive irrigation can cause
increases in erosion rates and the therefore increasing sediments loads of
streams and rivers. This is especially a problem when crops are planted on
slopes. Also overgrazing on riparian areas (areas adjacent to streams) can
result in erosion and increased stream sedimentation. Biologically, increased
sedimentation can smother organisms, destroy wildlife and spawning areas,
threaten fish populations as temperatures are generally increased, reduce the
amount of light available for photosynthesis which causes a chain reaction as
food resources are limited. Physically, sediments can fill reservoirs to a
point where flooding occurs. Sediment can also carry pesticides and fertilizers
with it, contaminating the water ways.
Pesticides. Pesticides can enter groundwater by leaching
through soils, they can be washed away with run-off or eroded with sediments
into surface waters. Once in the waters there are several problems that the
pesticides cause:
a) One of the big problems is that pesticides are persistent
(they don't easily break down) in the environment. As a result of this
persistence, pesticides can easily accumulate in food chains (DDT is one such
chemical which does this but it has now been banned for use).
b) Pesticides can inhibit plant photosynthesis, interfere with
reproduction, respiration, growth and even kill aquatic life.
c) Most water treatment plants are unable to remove pesticide
residues so they remain in the drinking water and can threaten human health.
They can cause flu-like symptoms, some are carcinogenic and some can threaten
infants genetic structure.
Fertilizers. Farmers generally apply too much fertilizer
to their crops and this excess, particularly the nitrates can by easily leached
into lakes, streams and ground water. It can also be washed away with runoff or
eroded with sediments. Fertilizers can also have numerous affects once in the
water:
a) Fertilizers stimulate the growth of algae and other aquatic
plants. When increased aquatic vegetation dies, it consume a lot of the oxygen
causing the lake to become eutrophic, and changing the biota that was found
there.
b) When excessive amounts of nitrates are found in drinking
water it can be dangerous to humans, it can lead to blue baby syndrome and it
is believed that nitrates many be linked to stomach cancer.
Agricultural practices can be altered in several ways to reduce
the impacts that it has on the aquatic environment:
Saving water. There are several methods that can be used
to reduce the amount of water that is being applied to crops yet still ensure
that the crops are receiving enough water for optimum growth.
a) Trickle or drop irrigation. This technique involves
delivering water directly to a small area adjacent to individual plants rather
than applying it to the whole field where it can runoff or evaporate. This not
only reduces the amount of water required but it also results in less erosion
and it reduces the likelihood of soil salinization because water is only
applied to the plant directly as needed.
b) Plowing techniques. The way in which a field is plowed
can reduce the amount of water used. When a field is contour plowed the ridges
act to hold water so that it can be soaked into the ground, terracing the land
can also lead to the same results.
c) Crop types. Planting crops that are suited to local
climate reduces the amount of water required. If the climate is dry, then crops
such as wheat should be planted because they are a lot hardier when compared to
corn which requires a lot of water.
Fertilizer alternatives. One change that could
potentially alleviate a lot of problems is to switch from chemical fertilizers
to organic fertilizers. Organic fertilizers release nutrients at a slower rate
and plants can uptake them, they increase the ability of the soil to retain
water and hold soil particles together both which lead to decreased erosion and
consequently decreased sedimentation. Other changes include intercropping or
crop rotations both which reduce the need for inorganic fertilizers.
Pesticide alternatives. The use of pesticides can be
reduced by rotating crops so that pest do not establish themselves or by
multicropping where crops are planted with plants that have natural defenses
against pests or that support predators of pests.
In British Columbia, several different types of irrigation are
used depending on the crop and the area. Irrigation types include flood,
handmove, wheelmove, solid set, traveling guns, center pivots and trickle
irrigation. Even though trickle irrigation is one of the most efficient methods
for irrigating crops, it is only used in 3% of the cases, the abundance of
fresh surface waters in this province hasn't resulted in the need for this type
of irrigation yet. Compared to the rest of Canada, British Columbia and the
Prairie Provinces account for almost 92% of the irrigated land.
3.3.5 Energy Use
Industrialized agriculture requires energy for almost every
aspect of food production. Industrial agriculture substitutes the by-products
of energy use for both human labor and land and can increase yields by well
over 100 % when compared to traditional methods. This increase in productivity,
however, requires an increase in fossil fuel use by approximately 400 %. Some
agricultural economists believe that the continued expansion of industrial
agricultural methods into LDCs is manditory in order to meet
the food requirements of their expanding populations. Environmentalist, on the
other hand, suggest that this may not be possible because of the finite supply
of fossil fuels and because of the costs of the environmental damage due to
this method of agriculture.
As mentioned in the previous paragraph, industrial agriculture
requires large amounts of fossil fuel use. The following list outlines some of
the main industrial agricultural activities that consume fossil fuels:
Production of Nitrogen Fertilizers. It is
estimated that almost one third of the fossil fuel used in industrialized
agriculture is consumed by the production of nitrogen-based fertilizers. The
production of nitrogen fertilizers requires large amounts of natural gas for
the synthesis of ammonia. Nitrogen is commonly the most limiting nutrient to
plant productivity, and most intensive farming systems use large amounts of
this nutrient to increase yields per hectare. Some estimates suggest that
traditional farming systems in Africa could triple their productivity with
fertilization. Savings in energy can be accomplished by:
- Applying fertilizers more carefully to crops to reduce over
fertilization. Europeans use twice the fertilizer as compared to the average
North American farm without any difference in crop yields. This data suggests
that Europeans are applying too much fertilizer to their fields. More efficient
analysis of soil nutrient status and crop needs could reduce the problem of
over fertilization.
- Changing the method of application to the crop. In general,
surface applications of fertilizer only get 30-40 % of the nitrogen applied to
the crop. Using more efficient methods, like sub-surface banding, could
significantly reduce losses to the environment.
- Using crop rotations. The planting of legumes (peas, beans,
vetch, alfalfa, and leucaena trees) on alternative years can be used to
re-charge the soil with nitrogen naturally.
- Increasing the use of organic fertilizers. In China, the
efficient use of organic nutrients from animal wastes, compost and green manure
greatly supplements the use of inorganic fertilizers.
Irrigation. In the United States, 13 % of
agricultural energy consumption is used to pump water, primarily from
groundwater sources, for irrigation. Energy consumption could be decreased in
this process by employing more efficient irrigation systems that reduce loss of
water.
Mechanical Tillage of the Soil Surface. Tillage
and seedbed preparation consumes large amounts of energy for the operation of
machinery. The diesel fuel consumption for plow-based conventional tillage
systems ranges from 60-80 litres per hectare. New techniques, like
conservation tillage, have been developed where the
application of herbicides and the use of specially developed seeding machines
can replace the tilling process. This switch to this technology could reduce
energy consumption significantly. This technique also benefits the soil by
improving its structure and moisture holding capabilities.
Livestock Raising. Raising livestock requires
enormous quantities of fossil fuels. Energy is required for growing,
harvesting, processing and transporting animal feed, handling manure, and
maintaining climate controlled surroundings. Fuel savings could be produced by
developing more efficient means of livestock keeping and by reducing the
consumption of meat and other livestock products.
Food Processing. A lot of energy is required to
store, process, package, transport, refrigerate and cook both plant and animal
farm products. Studies in industrialized countries have revealed that for every
calorie of food consumed, on average, 10 calories of energy are used to
produce, process and package the product. For comparison sake, one unit of
human labor energy expended by the traditional farming techniques results in
approximately one unit of food energy for consumption.
Modern energy intensive agriculture can continue to expand for
perhaps several more decades. However, with depleting oil reserves, energy
prices are likely to escalate to a point where their use in industrial
agricutural systems will be too expensive. Several things can be done now to
minimize the use of fossil fuels. Farmers can begin to use local perpetual and
renewable energy sources including wind, water, sun, animal and crop wastes.
Agricultural systems can also be made more energy efficient. Some studies
suggest that the application of organic farming techniques can reduce energy
use by more than 40 %.
3.3.6 Habitat
Destruction and Biodiversity Reduction
Monocropping is a technique which is used by almost all
industrial agriculturists. This process of planting only a single crop can lead
to disastrous effects, not only in terms of erosion and loss of soil fertility,
but it has a profound effect on the biodiversity of an area.
Many different species are disappearing from the planet, being
replaced by crops that are genetically uniform and have large yields. India
once cultivated over 30,000 different varieties of rice, but today over 75 % of
production comes from fewer than 10 varieties. Vegetation is also disappearing
quickly in the tropical rainforests, where slash and burn agriculture is
common. The land is stripped of its native vegetation and replaced with cash
crops or livestock which end up being sold to the MDC's (most developed
countries). Many of the species being wiped out only grow in these areas so are
permanently lost.
Loss of biodiversity can result in:
Reliance on hybrid seeds. Hybrid seeds can be planted, tended
and harvested efficiently. They are genetically uniform, so an entire crop is
vulnerable to pests, disease, flood, and drought. As a result, what effects one
plant will effect the others in the same fashion. If there was genetic variety
within the crop, some plants may be wiped out by one of these factors but it is
likely that not all of them would be.
Species that are disappearing may have traits that could be used
by scientists to engineer new crop strains. For example, some of the crops
disappearing now may have been drought tolerant, a gene which could have been
integrated into a different species. Such reductions in biodiversity limits the
potential for future green and gene revolutions.
Scientists have recognized the problem of loss of genetic
diversity and have established seed banks to save remaining varieties. Many
crops, however, are disappearing faster than they can be located, collected and
stored in the seed banks. There are several problems with preserving crops in
seed banks. Firstly, seed could be lost due to a fire, power failures or
unintentional disposal, permanently destroying all collected seeds forever.
Finally, research has shown that when a plant is reintroduced into its native
area it may not do as well as it previously did do to changes in soil, flora
and climate of the area as the plant stopped evolving when it went into
storage.
Farmers can also help to avoid the problems that coincide with
loss of biodiversity by simply cultivating either several varieties of the same
crop (polyvarietal cropping) or several different species (intercropping),
which limits the likelihood of all plants dying due to a flood, disease, pests,
etc. Acceptance of non-traditional crops for food sources would also help
retain genetic diversity, such as the cocyam from West Africa and Latin America
which is as nutritious as a potato.
3.4 Sustainable
Agriculture
A sustainable agricultural system involves the modification of
agricutural techniques in both existing industrialized and traditional
agricultural systems in order to provide for the needs of current and future
generations while conserving natural resources. In order for a agricultural
system to be called sustainable the following requirements must be met:
- Soils conservation must be reached. In other words the soils
cannot be degraded by erosion, salinization, water logging or loss of soil
fertility.
- Water resources must be managed so that they are preserved yet
still meet crop needs.
- The system must be economically viable.
- The biological and ecological integrity of the system must be
preserved.
In order to achieve these requirements, a sustainable agricultural
systems incorporates parts of industrialized, traditional and new agricultural
systems in order to take advantage of local climates, soils and resource
systems. With such a wide variability in climate, soils and resources results
in there being no exact way to characterize sustainable farming, because each
field has different requirements. There are many ways to meet the goals of
sustainable agriculture, many of which are outlined as alternatives to some of
the problems with industrialized agriculture. There are some concepts, however,
that are common to all sustainable farms:
- Crop rotations. This is a central component of
almost all sustainable farming systems. It involves the succession of various
crops growing on a field. Rotating crops has many benefits to the farmer
including a natural weed and insect control and efficient nutrient cycling to
name a few. It has been found that when crops are rotated yields are 10-15%
above those of monocultures.
- Organic matter. Adding organic matter to the
soil is yet another essential constituent of sustainable agriculture. This
improves soil structure, enhances fertility, increases water storage capacity
and promotes the tilth (physical condition) of the soil making it easier for
plants to emerge from the soil and extend roots downward.
- Plant nutrients. To reduce the use of
inorganic fertilizers, sustainable systems tend toward biological sources for
plant nutrients. Green manure, where a crop is grown specifically to be plowed
into the ground not only increases the present organic matter, but it also
supplies many nutrients back to the soil, increasing plant productivity.
- Increase biological diversity. Emphasizing
small to medium scale production of a diverse mix of crops, increases
biological diversity. This can result in increased soil productivity which
means less inorganic fertilizers are needed, reductions in soil erosion and
reductions in pesticide use as crops that can be mixed that provide a habitat
for predators of pests. This practice can also protect farmers from economic
hardships due to the flooding of the market with a particular crop or the
wiping out of a crop from a disease.
- Integrated pest management
(IPM) is another common aspect of sustainable farming which
integrates both biological, mechanical and chemical methods to control pests
while minimizing the affects to the environment.
- Minimize fossil fuel use. When available,
local perpetual and renewable energy sources such as the sun, wind, water and
animal crop wastes should be used, rather than depending on non-renewable
fossil fuels.
In conclusion, sustainable farming, not only minimizes the
influence of farming on the environment but it also gives farmers more control
over their livelihood. Application of sustainable agriculture practices results
systems that are less prone to weather and changes in the marketplace. It also
cuts costs of running a farm by requiring lower applications of inorganic
fertilizers and pesticides. Yields from sustainable farms are generally lower
than those of conventional systems. However, profits in the long-run can be
higher because lower input costs and reduced environmental damage.
3.5 Agriculture in the
Thompson-Okanagan
The history of agriculture in the Okanagan spans nearly 150 years.
The earliest attempts at agriculture in this region were directed at raising
cattle and growing grain. By 1892 over 20,000 head of stock were being tended
to by some of the first 400 settlers in the valley. In the 1890s, the first
apple orchards were established. During that same decade, hops were also
planted, but were later abandoned for economic reasons. Tobacco was grown on a
large scale in the valley at the turn of the century, but it too had to be
abandoned in the 1930s because it was economically not viable. In the 1920s,
grapes were grown, first as a fruit crop and then later for the production of
wines. By 1985, the Okanagan and Similkameen Valley's contained 90 % of British
Columbia's orchards and 95% of the province's vineyards.
From Vernon south to the U.S. border, the Okanagan's climate is
ideal for growing fruit trees and grapes. It has mild winters with plenty of
snowfall for the protection of dormant trees and vines, cool springs that delay
budding, and long hot growing seasons that encourge excellent fruit
development. However, insufficient rainfall occurs during the hot summers and
crops growing in this climate must be supplied with additional water from
irrigation systems. Slight variations in micro-climate throughout the valley
cause different fruit crops to be grown in certain locations. In the south,
slightly warmer climates favor the growth of soft fruits like cherries,
apricots, and peaches. Slightly cooler climates occurring between Penticton and
Vernon best suit hardier crops such as apples. North of Vernon, the soils and
climate are better suited for dairy farming.
Agricultural methods in the Thompson-Okanagan are primarly
industrial in nature. This type of agricultural system relies on the extensive
use of irrigation, fossil fuels, fertilizers, and pesticides to achieve high
levels of productivity. The Thompson- Okanagan is also experiencing some of the
highest population growth rates in the provience of British Columbia. As a
result of these two factors, the following environmental problems have or will
develop:
- Because of rapid population growth and land-use change, the
size and number of farms is declining significantly. The problem with declining
farm space is that there are only two significant areas in Canada that can
sustain tender fruit and grape production, the Okanagan Valley and the Niagara
Peninsula. These areas supply Canadians with a secure fruit supply at
reasonable prices. Without it, unreliable foreign supplies would likely
increase in price as there is no domestic competition.
- The Okanagan and Similkameen Valleys are found in arid to
semi-arid climates. In these climates, evapotranspiration
greatly exceeds precipitation inputs and farmers must supplement their crop's
water needs through irrigation. Current data indicates that there is enough
water in the Okanagan to meet demand. However, future increases in the size of
human populations in this region will create competition for this water. The
fruit industry could adjust by implementing technologies, like trickle
irrigation systems, that save water. Trickle irrigation systems are
currently employed in only 10 % of existing farms.
- Many orchards are in close proximity to residential complexes,
schools and playgrounds resulting in human health dangers during spraying
periods. The application of these chemicals may also be reducing numbers of
individuals in certain sensitive nontarget species of amphibians, birds and
insects.
- Because of the Okanagan Valley's topography and hydrology, a
significant proportion of pesticide chemicals applied to fruit end up into the
valley's lakes. Some of these chemical require up to 200 years for degradation
into benign compounds. DDT which was used to fight coddling moth more than a
decade ago is still found in small concentrations in Okanagan Lake fish.
- Applications of fertilizer are causing the eutrophication
of aquatic systems of various size. Severe eutrophication can lead to blooms of
algae, anoxic conditions, species die-offs and species change.
- Applications of nitrogen-based fertilizers and irrigation water
on soils with low cation
exchange capacitycan cause soil acidification. To reverse this
process many farmers in the Thompson-Okanagan must lime (addition of calcium
carbonate) their land to raise soil pH levels high enough for good plant
growth.
- Poor farming techniques in many Thompson-Okanagan farms are
leading to the erosion of topsoil. Erosion is especially problematic in the
spring and fall months, when farm soils are devoid of vegetation.
Table of
Contents Next
|